I know most were never gonna get updates, but I think V5 has negated the need for any updates at all. The only updates I think are somewhat necessary are ones like Yanhe_Sweet, since power vocals are cool but way less versatile/harder to use on their own.
Unpopular Opinions
- Thread starter TheStarPalace
- Start date
I know most were never gonna get updates, but I think V5 has negated the need for any updates at all. The only updates I think are somewhat necessary are ones like Yanhe_Sweet, since power vocals are cool but way less versatile/harder to use on their own.
The V2 Engloids (+Piko) deserved updates tho
Getting onto more of a slightly different tangent, I am still peeved about V5's lack of backwards compatibility. Mostly re: the V2s, but also re: not being able to export a VPR as a VSQx.
Losing 5 native Engloids cut out just under a third of the native English banks (leaves us with Oliver, Hio, Avanna, DDR, Cyva, Cyman, Amy, and Chris). It's a real shame. Regardless of whatever anyone says, I will forever mourn that they can't be imported, since Pocaloid users have gotten them in with That One Super Simple/Fast Trick That I Won't Name Here In Case It's Against TOS, and they sound great and work well with all the new functions. Frustrating. Esp since these banks are still being sold by their companies. I was even able to buy a Ryuuto physical box from a Japanese not that long ago >:(
Not being able to export a VPR as VSQx is just plain weird to me. Having to use third party programs to try to do it is stupid. It goes without saying that a lot of users were on V3 and V4 still soon after V5 dropped, but now if someone makes a song in V5 and wants to share it with those users, they can't, so that user must either try the third party workarounds or upgrade to V5 if they want to. Or else make a VSQ themself ofc, but you get what I'm saying. It just kind of feels like another bid to try to push users to upgrade, and we all already made our complaints about V5's pricetag when it first dropped. So it's a shame
Not being able to export a VPR as VSQx is just plain weird to me. Having to use third party programs to try to do it is stupid. It goes without saying that a lot of users were on V3 and V4 still soon after V5 dropped, but now if someone makes a song in V5 and wants to share it with those users, they can't, so that user must either try the third party workarounds or upgrade to V5 if they want to. Or else make a VSQ themself ofc, but you get what I'm saying. It just kind of feels like another bid to try to push users to upgrade, and we all already made our complaints about V5's pricetag when it first dropped. So it's a shame
the woooorst is yumemi nemu because shes got the first AND the last name
Gumi eng needs an update for sure. I'm not sure if this counts as an update but I wish they made Ruby Sweet Ann, Avanna, ect. compatible with MACThe V2 Engloids (+Piko) deserved updates tho
V4 couldn’t export VSQxs as VSQs either, if memory serves, so it seems odd that V5 not exporting VSQxs is suddenly a problem. And while it IS sad that V2s can’t be imported, they weren’t at all lost; they come with their own editors, after all, and copies of V3 at least are extremely easy to come by for a decent price anymore; it’s functionally the same as V4 minus a few features that V2s couldn’t use anyway.
It’s sad, but ultimately, Yamaha is a business. V2 was fully retired during the early days of V4, so it’s only logical it wouldn’t be carried over afterward. At least it’s not a V1-type situation, where you have one option and one option only.
Or couldn't export V3 VSQx' either, alternatively V3 was made compatible with V4 VSQx' so it's odd V4 hasn't received last update to make it compatible with VPRs.
Yee but it's on limited stock only......while we're at this topic I can kinda tell why Zero-G is taking on CFM-loids
Bluhhh this got kinda long so I will spoiler again
Oh don't worry, I'm peeved about that as well! I have a fanmade patch that works for legit V2 that makes it run plugins, and one of them allows it to open VSQx's. It's the only way I survived back when the only editors I had were V1 and V2 
I've always thought Yamaha had a terrible backwards compatibility policy, this is just the current complaint LOL
From a business standpoint it makes sense to retire old stuff and move on in time, for sure. I don't recall an official retirement (please correct me if I'm wrong -- I have a *famously* bad memory,,), but I suppose we should place it around the time the Import Tool servers were taken down and you had to start asking companies directly for codes. Anyway it is nice that V2s come with their own editor, even if it is a bit limited in comparison! V3Es being cheap is nice but since it's mostly second-hand and often has to be bought with proxy services, I won't assume that all western users necessarily know about it or will go out of their way to get one.
...Anyway it's just frustrating since the banks themselves are compatible as they are (if you add them by registry you don't have to fudge new IDs or anything, V5 will accept them as they are -- at least, this going off of a friend who tested it out in a cracked version just to see, and they were recognized -- not to mention the arguably easier DDB swap) and work well with all the fancy new functions. The V2->V5 renders some brave souls post sound really nice too. So it's just disappointing from a V2 fan POV. I don't hold like an active grudge against V5 for it anymore, but it is a bummer. I can only be glad companies continue to sell their older banks to fans. Even if the V2 Editor pisses me off, I think the era was one of the best, and it'll be a real sad day when their codes run out the same way the V1 trio's have
Again, you make logical points and I don't disagree with them totally! But I will continue to be salty about it in my lil corner jafl;askdjf
I've always thought Yamaha had a terrible backwards compatibility policy, this is just the current complaint LOL
From a business standpoint it makes sense to retire old stuff and move on in time, for sure. I don't recall an official retirement (please correct me if I'm wrong -- I have a *famously* bad memory,,), but I suppose we should place it around the time the Import Tool servers were taken down and you had to start asking companies directly for codes. Anyway it is nice that V2s come with their own editor, even if it is a bit limited in comparison! V3Es being cheap is nice but since it's mostly second-hand and often has to be bought with proxy services, I won't assume that all western users necessarily know about it or will go out of their way to get one.
...Anyway it's just frustrating since the banks themselves are compatible as they are (if you add them by registry you don't have to fudge new IDs or anything, V5 will accept them as they are -- at least, this going off of a friend who tested it out in a cracked version just to see, and they were recognized -- not to mention the arguably easier DDB swap) and work well with all the fancy new functions. The V2->V5 renders some brave souls post sound really nice too. So it's just disappointing from a V2 fan POV. I don't hold like an active grudge against V5 for it anymore, but it is a bummer. I can only be glad companies continue to sell their older banks to fans. Even if the V2 Editor pisses me off, I think the era was one of the best, and it'll be a real sad day when their codes run out the same way the V1 trio's have
Again, you make logical points and I don't disagree with them totally! But I will continue to be salty about it in my lil corner jafl;askdjf
EDIT:
THAT MADE ME MAD TOO. Why was V4's VSQx different from V3's in the first place? LOL. Anyway yeah it'd be nice if V4 were made to accept VPR's, or if V5 were made to export as VSQx. V2-V4 users being SOL if they want to use a V5 user's VPR is a real bummer imo!Or couldn't export V3 VSQx' either, alternatively V3 was made compatible with V4 VSQx' so it's odd V4 hasn't received last update to make it compatible with VPRs.
Yee but it's on limited stock only......while we're at this topic I can kinda tell why Zero-G is taking on CFM-loids
Also yeah, sadly they are running out sinceI heavily doubt any V2s will be renewed once their codes are gone, if a V3 like SeeU isn't. It's sad:<
*Cough cough* there where vsq exporter plugins for v3 and v4 there where even midi exporters for v1. With v5 there is no plugin support so a person couldn't even make a exporter in the engine if they wanted to.
Honestly if Yamaha wanted to retire v2 I'm surprised they made the upgrading cost to be so high because they honestly made a problem for them. Especially with v5 dev costs being so high
Honestly if Yamaha wanted to retire v2 I'm surprised they made the upgrading cost to be so high because they honestly made a problem for them. Especially with v5 dev costs being so high
Last edited:
But it's not native to the editors, it's no different than using utaformatix for V5 at this point.
Agreed, although it was semi convenient to have the midi/VSQ exporter in-editor for V4 at least. I'm sure some brilliant soul will find a way to add it eventually though, like they did for V2! I really ought to DL utaformatix, although I've heard mixed reviews. Have you used it?
That's fair! I'm UTAU user so I'm lenient with this type of stuff lol.Agreed, although it was semi convenient to have the midi/VSQ exporter in-editor for V4 at least. I'm sure some brilliant soul will find a way to add it eventually though, like they did for V2! I really ought to DL utaformatix, although I've heard mixed reviews. Have you used it?
I dunno whether it has dl version but I use the online one super often, it has always worked wonders except when you convert it to VPRs, it has issues witht the Style feature, I just convert to VSQx whenever I need to use something for V5
Last edited:
LOL that's fair. A friend gave me a quick UTAU English tutorial recently, so I may try to delve into that :>
Ah, online, my bad. But that's a good tip then re: just converting to VSQx, thank you! I'll keep that in mind when I use it eventually ;D
Unpopula opinion2:
Vocaloid is most know for Miku, that cuz Vocaloid get the fame of software for "Kawaii desu voices"
That's why people tend to hate or think it's just childish
Most of the people Ask me for vocaloid always think in Miku or tend to say: "I don't like, It's all japanese voice to sound like little girl(loli)"
I don't care if you don't like but better inform, I used to thought like that
Vocaloid is most know for Miku, that cuz Vocaloid get the fame of software for "Kawaii desu voices"
That's why people tend to hate or think it's just childish
Most of the people Ask me for vocaloid always think in Miku or tend to say: "I don't like, It's all japanese voice to sound like little girl(loli)"
I don't care if you don't like but better inform, I used to thought like that
I agree that V5’s quite high for anyone not ready to jump in and commit, but it had no tie to V5. V2 retirement was already in talks by V3 and rolled out before V5 was even conceptialized. At this point I think people are just pointing fingers. I don’t understand or agree with everything Yamaha does by any means, but I stand by the belief that retiring V2s was a perfectly logical business decision. Sad though it is and unfair though it may seem, they’re largely only appealing to hobbiests like us, and that’s just not who they’re marketing to anymore.
OK, here we go. (I might be regurgitating some of these points, but whatever)
- I love MEIKO V3 as a voicebank & as character, but her English VB is borderline unusable (I've had her for at least 4 years now & I feel much better using Miku V4 English for my needs who I've had for at least 3 or 4 months)
- Love Yuzuki Yukari, but outside of the Jun VB, Lin & Onn have the worst quality
- Kizuna Akari needs more love
- I want to see more Vocaloids of rock singers released for use, like ToshI from X Japan or Kyo from Dir en grey (they both have insane vocal ranges & are bilingual to an extent)
- I love MEIKO V3 as a voicebank & as character, but her English VB is borderline unusable (I've had her for at least 4 years now & I feel much better using Miku V4 English for my needs who I've had for at least 3 or 4 months)
- Love Yuzuki Yukari, but outside of the Jun VB, Lin & Onn have the worst quality
- Kizuna Akari needs more love
- I want to see more Vocaloids of rock singers released for use, like ToshI from X Japan or Kyo from Dir en grey (they both have insane vocal ranges & are bilingual to an extent)
This might have been mentioned before on this thread, but I'll say it anyway - Miku/Luka as a ship is extremely overrated.
Considering that Miku and Luka have canon ages....isnt it a big age-gapey too? Idk that ship kinda makes me a bit uncomfortable....
(no they don't, their ages are an idea that can be used if you want to, but they aren't "canon". Crypton stated this many many times, that there are no rules for how their characters are represented (and this is the case for basically all Vocaloids). There is no canon, just ideas the companys give you that you don't have to follow. Just like how they many times had to clarify that Rin and Len are not twins or related, but you can see them like that if you want to.)
I'm a little late here, I will try
Chinese Vocaloids are better then Japanese Vocaloids
Dex & Dina are kinda boring
Utatane Piko is not underrated
All vocal synths except for Vocaloid, UTAU, SynthV & CeVIO are super underrated
AHSoftware is basically good at everything
Korean synths in general are underrated
Russian UTAUs are very good but the only one that is barely noticed in M1NT0
I like that Haiyi sounds like she is chewing bread when she sings, its cute
Miku's Chinese tone is better then her English and Japanese tone
Kuzutokaze UTAU's are the best UTAU group
It's sad that there are so many abandoned UTAUs
Most fanloids are unoriginal
Chinese Vocaloids are better then Japanese Vocaloids
Dex & Dina are kinda boring
Utatane Piko is not underrated
All vocal synths except for Vocaloid, UTAU, SynthV & CeVIO are super underrated
AHSoftware is basically good at everything
Korean synths in general are underrated
Russian UTAUs are very good but the only one that is barely noticed in M1NT0
I like that Haiyi sounds like she is chewing bread when she sings, its cute
Miku's Chinese tone is better then her English and Japanese tone
Kuzutokaze UTAU's are the best UTAU group
It's sad that there are so many abandoned UTAUs
Most fanloids are unoriginal